Ending Sentences with Prepositions

For generations, English speakers and writers have grappled with a contentious rule of grammar: the supposed impropriety of ending sentences with prepositions. This guideline has roots deep in the annals of linguistic history, drawing from principles more suited to Latin than to the organic flow of English. Its persistence in educational settings has led many to question its relevance and applicability in contemporary writing and speech.

The debate surrounding ending sentences with prepositions is not just a matter of grammatical pedantry. Still, it touches on broader themes of language evolution, clarity of expression, and the balance between formal rules and communicative efficiency. With the dynamic nature of English, rigid adherence to rules that stem from a misunderstanding of the language’s structure can sometimes hamper rather than help communication.

This blog post aims to unravel the intricacies of ending sentences with prepositions, offering a fresh perspective on when and why it might be acceptable—or even preferable—to end a sentence with a preposition. By delving into the historical origins of the rule, examining the stance of modern linguistics and style guides, and providing practical advice for navigating formal and informal contexts, we hope to demystify this topic for writers and speakers alike. Join us as we explore the legitimacy of ending sentences with prepositions in the landscape of modern English.

Part 1: Understanding the Rule

Origins of the Rule

The admonition against concluding sentences with prepositions is a linguistic artifact inherited from Latin grammar rules, where such a construction is syntactically impossible. When English grammarians of the 17th and 18th centuries sought to lend the language a more scholarly veneer by aligning its rules with Latin, this particular guideline was adopted and promoted. Figures such as John Dryden and other literary purists championed this cause, inadvertently cementing a rule many argue was never naturally suited to English’s Germanic roots.

Rationale Behind the Rule

Advocates for maintaining the rule often cite clarity and formality as primary reasons. The writer or speaker crafts a more refined and precise statement by avoiding sentence-ending prepositions.
Example: consider the difference between “This is the issue we must deal with” and “This is the issue with which we must deal.” The latter is posited as more formally correct, though it may sound stilted or overly formal to modern ears.

Exceptions and Misinterpretations

Over time, the rule for ending sentences with prepositions has been subject to reevaluation, with linguists and style guides noting that adherence should not come at the expense of natural, clear expression. Common misunderstandings include the belief that ending a sentence with a preposition is universally incorrect, which ignores the fluidity and evolving nature of the English language. In many cases, attempting to avoid a terminal preposition leads to awkward or convoluted sentences that detract from the message’s clarity.

Examples:

• Natural: “What are you talking about?”
• Awkward Avoidance: “About what are you talking?”

Part 2: Modern Perspectives on Grammar and Usage

Changing Language, Changing Rules

Language is not static; it evolves in response to speakers’ needs, incorporating new words, discarding others, and sometimes reshaping its structure. With its rich history of influences—from Norse invasions to Norman French governance—English exemplifies this dynamism. Modern linguistics, embracing a descriptivist approach, seeks to document and understand language as it is used rather than prescribing strict rules that might constrain natural expression. This perspective recognizes that the “rules” of language are often guidelines reflecting common usage rather than immutable laws.

Authority and Style Guides

Modern style guides and grammar experts increasingly adopt this flexible approach to language, including treating prepositions. For instance:

• The Chicago Manual of Style acknowledges that while it’s possible to avoid ending sentences with prepositions, such avoidance is unnecessary for all contexts, especially if it leads to awkward constructions.
• The APA Style Guide similarly allows for sentence-ending prepositions when rephrasing the sentence would result in awkwardness or ambiguity.
• Merriam-Webster’s Dictionary of English Usage goes a step further, asserting that there is no rule in English prohibiting ending a sentence with a preposition.

These authoritative voices in writing and publishing reflect a broader acceptance of ending sentences with prepositions, provided they serve clarity and coherence.

Real-world Applications

Notable authors and respected publications often implement ending sentences with prepositions, underscoring the acceptance of this practice in contemporary writing. From journalistic pieces in “The New York Times” to literary works by authors like J.K. Rowling and Ernest Hemingway, the preposition at the end of a sentence is a tool for effective communication, not a grammatical faux pas to be avoided at all costs.

Part 3: Navigating Formal and Informal Contexts

Formal Writing

In highly formal writing, such as academic research, legal documents, and certain types of business communication, adhering to traditional rules—including those concerning prepositions—can be advisable. This approach may align with the expectations of a specific audience or institutional guidelines. However, even in these contexts, clarity should remain paramount. If avoiding a sentence-ending preposition makes a sentence awkward or unclear, it may be better to leave it in place.

Tips for Avoiding Awkwardness:

• Rewrite the sentence to maintain clarity while observing traditional guidelines, if possible.
• Consider whether rephrasing adds to the sentence’s clarity or merely adheres to a perceived rule.

Informal Writing

The natural flow of language takes precedence in informal writing, such as personal emails, blogs, and social media posts. Ending a sentence with a preposition is acceptable but often preferable for maintaining the conversational tone and authenticity of the communication. The key is authenticity and ease of understanding.

Knowing Your Audience

The decision to end a sentence with a preposition should be guided by the writer’s understanding of the audience and the context of the communication. Awareness of the audience’s expectations and the purpose of the text can help writers balance formal rules and effective communication.

• Formal Audience: Might appreciate adherence to traditional grammatical guidelines.
• General Audience: Likely values clarity and naturalness over strict grammatical conformity.

Part 4: Practical Tips for Writers

The choice to end a sentence with a preposition should be informed, not just a matter of following or flouting a rule. Here are some practical tips for writers navigating this decision:

When to Break the Rule

1. Clarity and Naturalness: If avoiding a preposition at the end makes the sentence awkward or unclear, it’s probably better to leave it where it is. Aim for natural, easily understood constructions.
2. In Questions: It’s often natural to end questions with prepositions in English. For example, “What are you looking for?” is much more conversational and clear than “For what are you looking?”
3. With Phrasal Verbs: Some verbs and prepositions form a semantic unit (phrasal verbs), and separating them can confuse the meaning. For instance, “She put up with it” shouldn’t be awkwardly rephrased as “She put with it up.”

Examples and Exercises

• Rewriting Exercise: Provide sentences that end with prepositions and challenge readers to rewrite them without changing the meaning. Then, discuss which version sounds more natural and why.
• Identification Exercise: List sentences where ending with a preposition is and isn’t preferable. Ask readers to identify which is which and why, reinforcing that context matters.

Conclusion

The debate over ending sentences with prepositions is emblematic of the larger conversation about language rules versus language use. As we’ve explored, the rigid prohibition against terminal prepositions doesn’t hold much water in modern English usage. Both historical insights and contemporary linguistic analysis suggest that clarity, coherence, and audience expectations should guide our writing choices more than outdated rules.

Summarizing Key Insights

• The prohibition against ending sentences with prepositions comes from a misapplication of Latin rules to English, a fundamentally different language.
• Modern style guides and linguists embrace a more nuanced, descriptive approach to grammar, acknowledging that ending sentences with prepositions can be perfectly acceptable.
• The choice between following and bending this rule should be informed by the context, the audience’s expectations, and the imperative of clear communication.

Empowering Writers

As writers, we have the agency to choose how we express ourselves, guided by the principles of effective communication rather than rigid adherence to rules. Understanding the rationale behind grammatical guidelines—and when they can be flexibly applied—empowers us to make informed decisions that enhance our writing and connect more meaningfully with our audience.

Further Exploration

For those eager to dive deeper into the intricacies of English, countless resources await. From comprehensive grammar guides to interactive language learning platforms, the tools at your disposal are more accessible than ever. Engage with these materials, challenge yourself with new exercises, and remain curious and open to discovery. We offer a line of comprehensive grammar and punctuation courses and feature a mastery quiz bundle to cement your further mastery of grammar and punctuation. Feel free to access the endorsed resources below to enhance your learning experience.

• Art of Grammar Courses
  Master the art of language with our comprehensive Grammar 101/102, Punctuation 101/102, and Mastery Quiz courses. Perfect your writing skills with expert guidance and quizzes tailored to reinforce your understanding of grammar and punctuation rules.
• Chicago Manual of Style
  Dive into the definitive guide for writers, editors, and publishers with our Chicago Manual of Style course. Explore the intricacies of citation, formatting, and language usage to elevate your writing to professional standards.
• Garner’s Modern English Usage
  Embark on a journey through the nuances of contemporary English usage with Garner’s Modern English Usage. Delve into Bryan A. Garner’s authoritative insights to refine your language skills and master the subtleties of modern communication.
• The AP Stylebook
  Navigate the complexities of journalistic writing with the AP Stylebook, your essential companion for media communication. Learn the rules and conventions of the Associated Press style to ensure accuracy and consistency in your news reporting and writing.
• APA Style
  Master the standards of academic writing with the APA Style Guide, your indispensable resource for scholarly communication. Gain proficiency in citing sources, formatting manuscripts, and adhering to APA guidelines to produce polished research papers and publications.
• Fowler’s Dictionary of Modern English Usage
  Unlock the richness of the English language with Fowler’s Dictionary of Modern English Usage, curated to refine your language precision and fluency. Delve into the timeless wisdom of H.W. Fowler’s insights to navigate contemporary language dilemmas and enhance communication skills.